When I was 11 or 12, a popular local newspaper columnist was encouraging kids in our area to raise money for an organization focused on efforts to end muscular dystrophy. Taking up the challenge, my brother and sisters and I and some friends organized a neighborhood carnival to raise money for the organization.
The carnival was a success–everyone had fun and we raised some money. Now, the charity that received our contribution had a solid reputation. But of course, the focus was entirely on the fundraising event and no questions were asked about how the money would be used. And why would we ask questions? There was simply a trust the money raised would be used well.
That may have been fine back then, and under that particular set of circumstances. But is the “no questions asked” approach when it comes to supporting charities and causes the best approach today?
The culture around supporting causes that many of us grew up with is still the culture today. Yet questions are rarely asked about where the money is actually going and how it will be used.
Where Does the Money Go?
Breast Cancer Action, in 4 Questions to Ask Before You Walk for Breast Cancer, notes that much of the money raised in cancer fundraising walks is often unaccounted for. As an example, it points out that The Avon 39 Walk to End Breast Cancer raised about $34 million from walks in 2015, but lists on its website only about $18 million as having been given in grants to breast cancer organizations, leaving the rest of the money raised by walk participants unaccounted for.
There’s often an implication that proceeds from cancer-related fundraisers will go toward cancer research, but that is not necessarily the case. Breast Cancer Action, in the same piece, notes this:
For example, the very name of the Susan G. Komen Race for the Cure® Series suggests that the money raised from these walks will go to research. But Komen’s website states that only 25% of the money raised goes to their “research and training grants program,” a category that doesn’t even reveal how much is going to research. Komen has long been criticized for their small percentage of investment in research funding. A large portion of Komen’s budget goes to “raising awareness” and early detection programs.
Is there a better way to support causes and charities that are important to us? The other approach, of course, involves choosing organizations to contribute to based on value rather than name only.
A first step, in my opinion, is deciding what we want to accomplish with our valuable time or our donations. Among breast cancer charities, for example, there are excellent organizations that serve patients directly, including patients in medically underserved populations; that support innovative approaches to research; or, that work to increase understanding of the environmental causes of breast cancer.
And then, once we’ve identified the type of organization we’re interested in, we really need to do our homework. Organizations that evaluate and/or rate charities–such as Charity Navigator, Charity Watch and the BBB Wise Giving Alliance are a helpful source of information. And for smaller charities that aren’t reviewed by the rating agencies, the organizations’ IRS Form 990s–which report on their activities, governance and financial information–can be accessed on the GuideStar website.
Charity Navigator rates charities by evaluating two broad areas of performance–Financial Health and Accountability & Transparency. It says that its ratings “show givers how efficiently a charity will use their support today, how well it has sustained its programs and services over time, and their level of commitment to being accountable and transparent.”
Charity Navigator has also set a goal of adding a third rating dimension–Results Reporting–to evaluate how well a charity is doing in providing information to donors about its actual performance. In an August 2015 update on Results Reporting, CN said that “while some organizations are trailblazers and are well underway in their collection and publishing of results data, the majority of organizations have little information they are making publicly available.” In the meantime, while it continues to work on how best to evaluate this dimension, CN is publishing information on each charity’s top programs and how much they spend on each of them.
Cancer Research Charities
So, what if you want to make a donation to an organization that is focused specifically on cancer research?
Doing a search on Charity Navigator, I found 18 organizations that it assigns 3- and 4-star ratings (its top 2 ratings) and that also have at least two-thirds of their program expenses going to cancer research. Those 18 organizations tend to fall into these three groups:
- There are four organizations out of this group that support or engage in general cancer research:
Stand Up 2 Cancer (Entertainment Industry Foundation)
Damon Runyon Cancer Research Foundation
UCLA Jonnson Cancer Center Foundation
- There are two major medical research centers, both of which have 4-star ratings, that emphasize cancer research along with other types of medical research:
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Huntington Medical Research Institutes
- And there are 12 organizations that have 3- or 4-star ratings and support research on specific types of cancer, including breast cancer, prostate cancer, pancreatic cancer, lung cancer and blood cancers, as well as childhood cancers:
Alex’s Lemonade Stand Foundation
Breast Cancer Research Foundation
CURE Childhood Cancer
Dr. Susan Love Research Foundation
Leukemia Research Foundation
Lustgarten Foundation for Pancreatic Cancer Research
Midwest Athletes Against Childhood Cancer
MPN Research Foundation (blood cancers)
Prostate Cancer Foundation
United Against Lung Cancer
Vera Bradley Foundation for Breast Cancer
In future posts, we’ll take a closer look at a few of these organizations individually. We may also look at some that are not on this list.
Results may be hard to assess, but transparency around goals and how the organization’s money has been allocated and what has been accomplished with it seems to be a good starting point. I’ll do the homework on some of these organizations, and share what I’ve learned in future posts.
Supporting Breast Cancer Charities: A Better Way
Making a Difference: Contributing to Cancer Charities
Charity Review: Stand Up To Cancer
Charity Review: Cancer Research Institute
Charity Review: Dr. Susan Love Research Foundation
Charity Review: Breast Cancer Research Foundation
Photo Credit: Zerbor via Shutterstock